The End of an Era: Pakistan’s Shift from Net-Metering to Net-Billing
Pakistan’s renewable energy
landscape is undergoing a seismic shift. Following months of speculation, the
National Electric Power Regulatory Authority (NEPRA) has officially notified
the Prosumer Regulations 2026, marking the end of the traditional
net-metering system and replacing it with a "net-billing" framework.
This move has ignited a fierce
debate between the government, which cites grid stability and financial equity,
and solar users who feel penalized for investing in clean energy.
What is Changing? From 1:1 Exchange to Buy-Back Rates
Under the previous Net-Metering
system, solar prosumers (consumers who also produce energy) enjoyed a 1:1 unit
exchange. If a household exported one unit of electricity to the grid during
the day, it could offset one unit consumed at night.
The new Net-Billing policy
fundamentally changes this math:
- Buy-back Rate:
Excess electricity exported to the grid will now be purchased by utilities
at the "national average energy purchase price," estimated at
approximately Rs. 11 per unit.
- Retail Rate:
When these same users pull electricity from the grid at night or during
peak hours, they will continue to pay the full retail tariff, which often
exceeds Rs. 40 per unit.
- Taxation:
Former Finance Minister Miftah Ismail highlighted a further disparity: the
Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) adds an 18% sales tax on the Rs. 40 units
purchased but may deduct tax from the Rs. 11 units sold back, widening the
financial gap for solar owners.
New Regulatory Constraints
The 2026 regulations introduce
several technical and administrative hurdles:
- Reduced Contract Length: The standard contract term for new solar connections
has been slashed from seven years to five years.
- Capacity Caps:
Residential systems are limited to the consumer's "sanctioned
load" and capped at a maximum of 1 megawatt.
- Grid Restrictions:
New connections will be barred if solar generation on a local transformer
reaches 80% of its rated capacity.
- Added Costs:
Prosumers must now pay a non-refundable "concurrence fee" of Rs.
1,000 per kilowatt and bear all costs for grid upgrades and bi-directional
meters.
The Government’s Defense: Equity and Grid Stability
Power Minister Sardar Awais Khan
Leghari defended the changes in the Senate, arguing that they are necessary
"regulatory adjustments" rather than a policy reversal. The
government’s core argument rests on two points:
- The Burden on Non-Solar Users: With 466,000 net-metering users generating nearly
7,000 MW, the government argues that maintaining high buy-back rates
places an unfair financial burden on the 34 million consumers who cannot
afford solar and must cover the fixed costs of the national grid.
- Legacy Protection:
The Minister clarified that existing contracts will be honored
until their expiry, meaning current users will not see an immediate
retrospective change.
Expert Criticism and Public Backlash
The policy has drawn sharp criticism
from across the political spectrum and energy sector:
- "Punishing Efficiency": Senator Sherry Rehman argued the rules "punish
citizens for producing clean energy" and contradict Pakistan’s global
climate commitments.
- Inefficiency Shield:
Critics like Mohammad Zubair and Ammar Rashid claim the policy aims to
protect the interests of Independent Power Producers (IPPs) and cover the
inefficiencies of Distribution Companies (DISCOs) rather than solving the
underlying debt crisis.
- The "Off-Grid" Threat: Former ministers Taimur Saleem Jhagra and Hammad Azhar
warned that by making the grid less attractive, the government is
incentivizing users to invest in batteries and go completely off-grid.
This could lead to a "death spiral" for the national grid as
more high-paying consumers leave the system.
The Outlook for Solar in Pakistan
While the government maintains that
these reforms are essential to stabilize electricity tariffs for the masses,
the shift to net-billing significantly extends the "payback period"
for rooftop solar investments.
As the Senate defers resolutions
against the policy and the regulator stands firm, the solar industry in
Pakistan faces a new reality: the era of "free" unit-for-unit storage
in the national grid is over. For many, the next logical step will be a shift
toward hybrid systems with battery storage, further distancing private citizens
from a struggling national power infrastructure.

Comments
Post a Comment